Be the Best Lawyer in the Boardroom (6 Steps)
The real power move isn’t knowing every rule. It’s knowing exactly when to flip the board.
👋 Subscribe and join all the smart tech legal folks getting the latest insights, trends, and updates
Strategy Over Showmanship
I’ve sat through enough executive-filled meetings to know this: the best lawyer in the room is NOT the one who talks the most, quotes the most case law, or wins every debate.
It’s the one who says the least, asks the right questions, and makes everyone else quietly rearrange their mental chessboard because they understand the business well enough to know which pieces actually matter.
You don’t get there by being clever for clever’s sake. You get there by understanding that in the boardroom, every word you say either builds trust or burns it.
Steps to Be a Killer Board Attendee:
1. Learn to See the Board Like a Chess Player, Not a Referee
Early in my career, I thought my job in the boardroom was to be the rule enforcer. Spot the risks, flag the clauses, point out that “technically” the bylaws say X.
And you know what? That was fine. Safe. Predictable. Like being the hall monitor in school…you are respected in theory, ignored in practice.
The problem was, I was playing reactive chess. Just moving pieces to block threats, never shaping the game. If someone made a bad move, I’d wave the rulebook instead of flipping the table (metaphorically…most of the time).
Then I watched a veteran GC completely change the trajectory of a decision without quoting a single statute. The board was reviewing a new product. The branding team had mock-ups, marketing had a rollout plan, and everyone was grinning like they’d already hit “publish” to the website.
The GC didn’t pull out a binder or give a lecture on IP law. They just asked:
Do we actually own the code, or did the contractor keep the rights?
It was like someone cut the music at a party. The smiles froze. A few heads turned toward the product lead. Someone muttered, “We’ll need to check.”
That single question yanked the conversation from “When do we launch?” to “Can we legally launch at all?”
As a chess player you’re not just enforcing the rules but rather anticipating the next five moves and making sure the team (“company”) is not about to walk into checkmate wearing a party hat.
The best lawyers don’t just know the law. They know exactly where to place the one question that changes the whole board.
2. Don’t Show Up as “The Lawyer.” Show Up as a Strategic Peer
I learned this one the hard way.
Early in my career, I thought my value in meetings with executives was directly proportional to how many legal issues I could spot in an hour.
The result? I became “the department of no” with a tie. People would smile politely, let me finish, and then carry on talking about market share and product launches like I’d just read them the warranty terms on a toaster they didn’t buy.
The turning point came when I realized the executives didn’t need a human statute book in the room. They needed someone who could connect the dots between a legal issue and an actual business outcome they cared about.
Like the time senior executives were discussing a partnership with a flashy new vendor. The legal risks were real, but instead of leading with, “Here’s the indemnity language I’m concerned about,” I opened with:
If this deal goes south, it could delay our product roadmap by six months, which means the next two quarters are toast.
Same facts. Totally different reaction. Suddenly, I wasn’t the lawyer slowing things down; I was now the person helping them avoid walking straight into an operational sinkhole.
That’s the thing, awesome lawyers don’t lead with the law. They lead with the strategy, and they make the law fit into it. Because nothing clears out a room full of executives faster than legal jargon no one understands.
3. Keep an Arsenal of One-Line Kill Shots
You don’t need to argue every point. Sometimes, all it takes is one well-placed question to make the whole room slam on the brakes.
Over time, I built a shortlist of questions that can stop senior executives without making me the villain:
“What happens to our obligations if someone else buys them, or buys us?”
“What will this cost us to undo?”
“If we had to defend this decision in the press or in court, what's the headline?”
“Are we relying on people to act exactly as we think they will?”
“Who carries the blame if this fails, and who carries the bill?”
These aren’t trick questions. They’re more like speed bumps that are annoying in the moment, but are also the thing that keeps you from launching straight off the cliff in a convertible while everyone’s still arguing over the playlist.
One time, the team was ready to sign a partnership with a well-known vendor. Then I asked, “What’s our plan if their system goes down for a week?” The smiles faded. The vendor’s outage history wasn’t in the materials, and no one had talked about contingencies. We didn’t walk away, but the contract ended up with a business continuity section so tight you could bounce a quarter off it.
A good kill shot doesn’t make the lawyer look clever. It makes the team look prepared. And if you can deliver it with a calm, almost casual tone, even better.
Spotting the right moves is only half the game. It’s not just what you say that makes you a killer lawyer. It’s when and how you say it (which are points 4 - 6)
4. Read the Room, Not Just the Agenda
Here’s the thing about board meetings, the agenda is basically the conference room equivalent of airline safety cards. Nice to have, technically important, but 90% of the action is happening somewhere else.
The real meeting is in the side-eyes, the polite-but-strained smiles, and the just-a-bit-too-long silences after someone says, “This should be straightforward.”
(Newsflash: it’s never straightforward.)
Once, a senior executive was practically glowing over a new vendor partnership. l Everyone nodded like we’d just discovered fire…except the COO, who leaned back with their arms crossed like they were watching a slow-motion car crash.
I didn’t interrupt. I just filed that away and asked the COO later, “You didn’t say much…what’s missing for you?”
Turns out, the vendor had a habit of security breaches. Not in the materials. Not in the pitch. But definitely in the Google search results. And guess who would’ve been stuck explaining it to regulators? (Hint: not the marketing team.)
Reading the room isn’t about mind-reading. It’s about noticing when someone’s poker face is slipping and having the curiosity (and courage) to ask why.
Great lawyers don’t just listen to what’s being said. They pay attention to who’s quietly not saying it.
5. Use Stories, Not Statutes, to Win the Room
Early in my career, I thought the fastest way to be persuasive was to cite the law like I was auditioning for Law & Order: Boardroom Unit.
Under Section 5(b) of—
Cue the collective glazing of eyes.
Here’s a difficult truth. Quoting the law in a board meeting is like reading nutritional labels at a BBQ. Technically useful. Practically ignored.
What actually moves the room? Stories. Real, “this could happen to us” stories.
We were once debating whether to move all customer data to a shiny new cloud provider. I could’ve recited a list of regulatory risks that would put an insomniac to sleep. Instead, I told them about a peer company that had to spend $3M “ripping out” their brand-new system after regulators decided their setup violated data transfer rules.
Silence. Then someone asked, “Wait…could that happen to us?”
And just like that, we had everyone’s attention.
Great lawyers translate risk into something everyone in the room can picture, preferably in vivid, slightly terrifying detail.
6. Know When to Shut Up
This might be the hardest one, especially for lawyers. We’re trained to add words. Lots of them.
Early in my career, I thought I had to speak on every single topic to prove I belonged in the room. If I stayed quiet, they’d forget I was there.
Spoiler: they didn’t forget. They just started bracing themselves every time I leaned forward.
The truth is, the boardroom isn’t graded on participation. It’s graded on impact. The best lawyers are the ones who wait, listen, and then speak only when it matters. Because when they do, everyone knows this part is important.
Once, after 20 minutes of heated debate about whether to pivot product strategy, I finally said: “If we’re changing direction, we need to be ready for what that means to our regulatory commitments.”
Silence. Then the entire conversation shifted. Not because I was dramatic, but because the timing was right.
Now, I treat my boardroom comments like high-value poker chips. I only put them on the table when the stakes are worth it. That way, when I do speak, people don’t think, Here we go again. They think, This is about to matter.
The best lawyers know the power of the pause. And they’re not afraid to let other people fill it.
The Quiet Advantage
The best lawyer in the boardroom isn’t the loudest or the flashiest. They’re the one who sees the whole board, not just the current move. The one who asks the question everyone wishes they’d thought of first.
They make the conversation better without making it about themselves.
And if you do it right, you won’t just protect the company you’ll quietly become the person they can’t afford to leave out of the room.
Because in the end, the real power move isn’t getting the last word.
It’s making sure the right decision gets made.
Great article