When the Breach Hits the Fan
Behind the Curtain of a Cyber Meltdown. Your incident response playbook isn’t a binder, it’s a juggling act with regulators, lawyers, hackers, and your own board.
👋 Welcome to the OnlyLawyer newsletter! Each week I tackle legal topics for the tech industry — cybersecurity, data privacy, AI legal issues, and other current issues
The Public Story vs. the Real Story
When a breach hits the news, the headlines look simple:
“Global Insurer Allianz Confirms Data Breach.”
“Hackers Access Sensitive Information.”
“Company Investigating.”
That’s the press release version. Clean, controlled, carefully worded.
The real story? A breach is less a “clean announcement” and more like an orchestra where every instrument comes in out of tune, half the musicians are late, and the conductor is on fire.
So let’s pull back the curtain. What actually happens when a global company like Allianz discovers a breach?
Step 1: The “Oh S***” Moment
No breach starts with certainty. It starts with an email from security ops at 2 a.m. that says: “We’re seeing unusual activity.”
Inside the company, this moment spirals fast:
Security teams argue over whether it’s a false positive.
Someone asks if the backup server is impacted (nobody knows).
A VP says, “Do not email about this”—by email.
And the question nobody wants to ask yet: “Do we need to tell the regulators?”
In Allianz’s case, reports suggest the attackers were in for weeks before discovery. That’s not unusual. Detection isn’t a spotlight; it’s more like smelling smoke in a 50-story building and trying to find the match.
Step 2: The Shadow Wars
The public sees: “Allianz is investigating with third-party experts.”
What’s really happening:
Security and IT are scrambling to contain the breach, pulling plugs like it’s whack-a-mole.
Forensics is imaging systems, tracing logs, and quietly hoping the attackers didn’t clear everything.
Legal is setting up the privilege wall. That often means structuring the forensic engagement through outside counsel so reports don’t land straight into a regulator’s inbox later.
This is the privilege track no one talks about. While Security and IT are containing the fire, lawyers are running a parallel process under attorney–client privilege. Why? Because without it, every draft timeline, every “we think this is how they got in,” every worried email is discoverable in litigation.
Privilege doesn’t hide facts. But it does keep the messy, early, not-yet-corrected theories from becoming Exhibit A in the inevitable class action.
Step 3: The Threat Actor Plays Their Card
Here’s what the Allianz case underscores: sometimes, the breach notice doesn’t start with the company. It starts with the hacker.
Threat actors increasingly send the first breach notice themselves:
“We have your customer files. Pay up or we’ll publish.”
Or they dump a teaser on a leak site to force the company’s hand.
That means legal teams don’t just worry about regulators and customers. They’re also watching the dark web like a second inbox. If the hacker posts before you’ve notified, regulators ask: “Why are we reading about this on Telegram instead of hearing it from you?”
In Allianz’s case, reports surfaced on leak sites before the company went public. That dual-timeline (threat actor vs. corporate disclosure) is now standard.
Step 4: The Notification Maze
Here’s where it gets truly brutal. Every jurisdiction has its own rulebook:
The EU’s GDPR says: notify within 72 hours if risk is “likely.”
U.S. states each have their own laws (50+ versions of “promptly”).
China requires regulator notice before public disclosure.
India’s CERT rules mandate notification within 6 hours (yes, hours).
So what does a global GC do? You don’t sleep. You spin up a war room. You map data subjects across countries and pray your data mapping from last year’s audit is still accurate.
The joke in privacy circles: breach notification isn’t about speed, it’s about survival math. Who will fine us harder if we guess wrong? The EU, the FTC, or the plaintiffs’ bar?
Step 5: The Boardroom Theater
Now picture the board meeting. Allianz isn’t unique here. Every breached company plays the same scene:
Directors want to know, “How bad is it?” (You don’t know yet.)
They ask, “Was this preventable?” (Depends how honest you want to be.)
They suggest, “Can we just pay and make it go away?” (Cue compliance explaining why wire transfers to ransomware gangs make bad headlines and could violate sanctions law.)
This is where the best lawyer in the room isn’t the one with the thickest memo. It’s the one who can calmly say, “Here are the three decisions we need to make in the next 24 hours,” and keep everyone focused.
Step 6: Regulators Circle
With Allianz, regulators across multiple jurisdictions are already circling. And that’s the new normal: a single breach equals three parallel fights:
Data protection regulators: Was notification timely? Was security “appropriate”?
Financial regulators: Did disclosure obligations to markets kick in?
Litigation: Plaintiffs line up before you’ve even hit “send” on customer notices.
Think of it as a relay race where all three start running at the same time…and they’re all chasing you.
Step 7: The Public Script vs. the Private Panic
Public statement: “We are investigating, customer impact appears limited, and services remain operational.”
Private conversation:
“Wait, did we just discover backups were also compromised?”
“Who signed off on not patching that vulnerability?”
“Do not, under any circumstances, use the word ‘contained’ until we actually know.”
The hardest part of breach response isn’t technology. It’s credibility. One bad sentence in a press release can create more liability than the breach itself.
Lessons for GCs and In-House Counsel
So what do we actually take away from Allianz and the breaches that will follow it?
1. Privilege First, Facts Fast
Set up the privilege track from day one. Regulators don’t care about your early hunches, but plaintiffs’ lawyers will frame them as smoking guns.
2. Assume the Hacker Will Out You
If you’re waiting to “control the timing,” you’re already behind. Threat actors now double as press officers.
3. Global Breach = Global Headache
The more countries you operate in, the more timelines you juggle. Have your playbook ready before the breach, not during.
4. The Board Needs Direction, Not Statutes
Don’t show up with GDPR recitals. Show up with the three questions the board needs to answer that day.
5. Prepare for Dual Investigations
Every breach now has two investigations: the forensics you run, and the investigation regulators think you should have run. They rarely line up.
The Quiet Role of the Lawyer
Behind every breach headline, there’s a lawyer running three clocks: the regulatory clock, the litigation clock, and the “don’t make the board look foolish” clock.
And unlike IT, you can’t just reboot the system when it freezes.
The Allianz breach won’t be the last, or the worst. But it’s a reminder that in 2025, the lawyer’s job in a breach isn’t just to manage risk. It’s to choreograph chaos.
Because when the breach hits the fan, the difference between a disaster and a controlled burn usually comes down to whether Legal got involved in hour one or hour twenty-four.